At Jinxers...
Right you are, but it is your taste. While your input is generous, it conflicts with that of the author. Perhaps it delivered the heart-wrench to him, so he wanted to share it? A review saying why you didn't like it shouldn't be opinionated, it should be a critique on the composition, finesse or other things that were lacking, i.e., serious screw ups, out of tune, etc.
I have nothing else to say, other than that it rocked my socks off.